- The GTM Guild
- Posts
- Beyond Opens: Iterating with Reply Rates, Bounce Rates & Spam Flags
Beyond Opens: Iterating with Reply Rates, Bounce Rates & Spam Flags
Why the smartest GTM teams don’t chase vanity metrics—they refine campaigns with the signals that matter
In partnership with
Hello Everyone,
When most teams start with cold email, the first question is always: “What’s my open rate?”
It feels like the easiest metric to track and compare. But here’s the uncomfortable truth: open rates don’t always tell the real story. Between privacy settings, pixel blocking, and inflated numbers, opens can mislead more than they inform.
The best GTM operators know where the real signals lie: reply rates, bounce rates, and spam flags. These are not just numbers—they’re the feedback loops that help you iterate campaigns with precision. In this GTM Guild newsletter, let’s break down how to use each one strategically.
Is Your Amazon Strategy Actually Working?
Are you a fast-growing omni-channel brand? Do you know your Amazon profitability (and are you happy with it)?
At Cartograph, we’ve spent 7 years helping brands like OLIPOP, Starface, Rao’s, and 300+ brands in Food, Bev, Supplements, Beauty, Pet, and other categories scale profitably on Amazon.
No fluff. No bots. Click below for an Amazon audit from a real human with insights you can actually use.
1. Reply Rates: The True Measure of Engagement
Why it matters:
A reply—whether positive, neutral, or even negative—means your message got through and demanded attention. This makes reply rate the single best indicator of whether your outreach resonates.
How to use it:
Track positive vs. negative replies. A 5% reply rate with 80% positive responses is better than a 15% reply rate full of “unsubscribe” requests.
Test angles, not just wording. If replies are low, change the offer or value prop, not just the subject line.
Identify triggers. Did decision-makers respond more to ROI-driven language, or to pain-point storytelling? That insight guides your next campaign.
Benchmark:
Across B2B, a 3–8% reply rate is healthy. Anything below 2% means your targeting or messaging needs work.
Why it matters:
A high bounce rate doesn’t just waste effort—it hurts your sender reputation. ISPs monitor how often your emails fail to land, and too many hard bounces can flag you as a spammer.
How to use it:
Aim for <3%. Anything higher is a red flag for your data hygiene.
Separate soft vs. hard bounces. Soft bounces can mean temporary server issues, while hard bounces mean the address is invalid. Only the latter damages reputation.
Audit your source. If a particular data vendor or scraping tool consistently drives bounces, cut it off.
Iteration tip:
Run smaller tests first. Clean lists with validation tools before scaling campaigns. The best GTM teams treat list health like pipeline hygiene—it compounds over time.
3. Spam Flags: The Silent Killer
Why it matters:
Few things can tank your outbound engine faster than spam complaints. Even a tiny percentage of “Report Spam” clicks can trigger mailbox providers to reroute all your emails to junk.
How to use it:
Monitor closely. Even 0.1% spam complaints can damage domain reputation.
Look for patterns. If complaints spike after a particular template, tone, or CTA, that’s a sign the messaging feels pushy or irrelevant.
Warm up properly. Many spam issues are technical, not just content-driven. Domain warming, proper DKIM/SPF/DMARC, and healthy sending volumes are non-negotiable.
Iteration tip:
Don’t guess. Pair spam flag data with reply sentiment. If both are trending negative, your list targeting is off. If spam rises while replies are positive, check technical setup instead.
Kickstart your holiday campaigns
CTV should be central to any growth marketer’s Q4 strategy. And with Roku Ads Manager, launching high-performing holiday campaigns is simple and effective.
With our intuitive interface, you can set up A/B tests to dial in the most effective messages and offers, then drive direct on-screen purchases via the remote with shoppable Action Ads that integrate with your Shopify store for a seamless checkout experience.
Don’t wait to get started. Streaming on Roku picks up sharply in early October. By launching your campaign now, you can capture early shopping demand and be top of mind as the seasonal spirit kicks in.
Get a $500 ad credit when you spend your first $500 today with code: ROKUADS500. Terms apply.
Bringing It Together: Iteration as a System
The magic of outbound isn’t in writing the perfect email on the first try—it’s in rapid iteration. Reply rates, bounce rates, and spam flags form the holy trinity of feedback loops.
Reply rates tell you if your messaging resonates.
Bounce rates tell you if your targeting is clean.
Spam flags tell you if your sending practices are safe.
When you track these together, you get a full picture: not just “Did my email get opened?” but “Did it connect, did it deliver, and is it sustainable?”
Final Word
The best GTM teams treat outbound like product development. They ship small, track real signals, and iterate quickly. Chasing open rates is like chasing vanity downloads in SaaS—it looks good on paper but doesn’t build lasting growth.
Instead, obsess over replies, bounces, and spam flags. They’ll tell you the story of your market, your data, and your reputation. If you listen closely and adapt, you won’t just improve your campaigns—you’ll build a durable outbound engine that scales.
Some interesting reads…
Until next time,
— Team GTM Guild