How to Warm Up a New Domain Before You Send a Single Cold Email

In partnership with

Cold email is one of the most effective GTM (go-to-market) strategies — when done right. But if you’ve ever launched a campaign from a brand-new domain and watched your deliverability nosedive, you’ve learned the hard way: email isn’t just about what you send, it’s about the reputation behind the domain.

Internet Service Providers (ISPs) like Gmail, Outlook, and Yahoo are in the business of protecting their users from spam. To them, a new domain is an unknown sender with zero reputation. Blast out 500 emails on day one, and you’ll almost guarantee a fast trip to the spam folder.

That’s why domain warm-up is essential. Think of it as digital networking: you wouldn’t walk into a room of strangers and pitch 200 people at once. You’d introduce yourself slowly, build rapport, and earn trust. Warming up a domain is the same principle applied to inboxes.

Here’s a practical playbook for doing it right.

Step 1: Set Up the Basics (Before You Warm Up)

Before sending a single email, you need to make your domain technically trustworthy. That means:

• Custom domain: Use a dedicated domain for outreach (e.g., yourbrand.co instead of your main .com).

• Email authentication: Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records. These prove your messages are legitimate and not forged.

• Professional signature: Even in warm-up emails, use a clean, human-looking signature with your name, role, and company.

• Mailbox organization: Create your inbox, sent, and archive structure. ISPs monitor behavior beyond just sending.

Without these, warm-up won’t matter — you’ll be flagged before you begin.

Step 2: Start with Manual Sending

Automation can wait. In the first week, send small numbers of highly personalized emails manually. Think:

• 5–10 emails per day, not campaigns.

• Send to friends, colleagues, or even your own secondary inboxes.

• Ask them to open, reply, and engage with the message.

This creates a natural back-and-forth that signals to ISPs: these emails are wanted.

Step 3: Gradually Increase Volume

Once your domain has seen consistent positive engagement, you can begin ramping up. A common cadence looks like this:

• Week 1: 10–15 emails/day

• Week 2: 20–30 emails/day

• Week 3: 40–50 emails/day

• Week 4: 60–100 emails/day

By week four or five, you can safely run proper campaigns. The key is gradual growth — never spike your volume overnight.

Step 4: Use a Warm-Up Tool (Optional but Powerful)

There are dedicated tools (e.g., Instantly, Mailflow, Mailwarm) that automate engagement during warm-up. These services connect your inbox to a network of real accounts that:

• Open your emails

• Reply to them

• Pull them out of spam, if needed

This accelerates the process and makes it less manual, but it’s not a substitute for smart sending practices. Think of it as scaffolding, not a shortcut.

Step 5: Prioritize Engagement Quality

ISPs don’t just care about volume — they care about how people interact with your emails. To improve signals:

• Send short, conversational emails (avoid images, links, and attachments in early stages).

• Get real replies. Ask simple questions that invite one-line responses.

• Vary your sending times instead of blasting at the same minute each day.

• Don’t forget to open and respond to inbound mail in your new domain inbox.

The more your domain looks like a real human being using email naturally, the stronger your reputation becomes.

Step 6: Maintain Ongoing Health

Warming up isn’t a one-and-done task. To sustain domain health:

• Keep your bounce rates below 2%. Always validate lists.

• Segment and target carefully. Relevance reduces spam complaints.

• Monitor blacklists. Tools like MXToolbox help you stay aware.

• Continue mixing in positive engagements — not just cold campaigns.

Think of reputation as a credit score: easy to damage, harder to rebuild. Protect it.

The Payoff: Trust and Deliverability

A properly warmed-up domain doesn’t just improve deliverability — it sets the tone for every campaign that follows. Instead of battling spam filters, you’ll land in inboxes. Instead of looking like a stranger, you’ll look like a trusted sender.

Cold email works best when it doesn’t feel cold. But before your prospects ever read your subject line, their inbox provider has already judged you. Domain warm-up ensures that judgment is in your favor.

At GTM Guild, we believe execution beats theory. And in email, that execution starts before you send a single campaign.

Until next time,

— Team GTM Guild