- The GTM Guild
- Posts
- Subject Lines That Convert
Subject Lines That Convert
Proven Formulas to Get Your Cold Emails Opened
In partnership with
You can write the smartest cold email in the world — but if your subject line flops, no one will ever read it. It’s the digital equivalent of knocking on a door and being ignored.
The inbox is crowded. People are busy. And the brutal truth is: your subject line has about 2 seconds to earn attention. That’s why top senders rely on a handful of tested, repeatable formulas. Not gimmicks, not guesswork — frameworks built on psychology, brevity, and clarity.
In this GTM Guild edition, we’ll break down the formulas that consistently move the needle, show you why they work, and share how you can test them in your own campaigns.
So, how do you move from guessing to a reliable system?
The answer: lean on formulas that have been tested across industries and proven to lift open rates. Below, we’ll break down six of the most effective subject line approaches, why they work, and how you can adapt them to your own outreach.
Kickstart your holiday campaigns
CTV should be central to any growth marketer’s Q4 strategy. And with Roku Ads Manager, launching high-performing holiday campaigns is simple and effective.
With our intuitive interface, you can set up A/B tests to dial in the most effective messages and offers, then drive direct on-screen purchases via the remote with shoppable Action Ads that integrate with your Shopify store for a seamless checkout experience.
Don’t wait to get started. Streaming on Roku picks up sharply in early October. By launching your campaign now, you can capture early shopping demand and be top of mind as the seasonal spirit kicks in.
Get a $500 ad credit when you spend your first $500 today with code: ROKUADS500. Terms apply.
1. The Curiosity Hook
Humans can’t resist an open loop. A subject line that hints at something without giving it all away makes the reader click to “close the loop.”
Formulas to Try:
“Quick question about [specific topic]”
“Noticed something about [prospect’s company]”
“Did you mean to…?”
Why It Works: Our brains are wired to resolve curiosity gaps. This works especially well if your opening line delivers on the promise instead of bait-and-switching.
2. The Value Upfront
Sometimes, clarity beats cleverness. Telling people exactly what they’ll get in plain language reduces friction.
Formulas to Try:
“How [prospect’s role] can cut [pain point] in half”
“3 ways to fix [industry challenge]”
“Save 5 hours a week on [specific task]”
Why It Works: Prospects are busy. By being direct, you’re respecting their time and positioning yourself as a problem-solver, not just a salesperson.
People trust what others already use or approve of. If your subject line hints at authority or adoption, curiosity spikes.
Formulas to Try:
“Used by [credible company/brand]”
“[Number] companies are doing this right now”
“Why [well-known name] made the switch”
Why It Works: It reduces perceived risk. If others in their space are already onboard, the prospect is more likely to take a peek.
4. The Personalization Angle
Personalization isn’t just dropping in (first name). The best subject lines reference specifics that matter — things only relevant to that prospect.
Formulas to Try:
“Loved your post on [topic]”
“Idea for [prospect’s company/team name]”
“Congrats on [recent milestone] — quick thought”
Why It Works: It signals this isn’t a mass send. Relevance increases odds of engagement, even if the pitch inside is modest.
5. The Brevity Play
Sometimes less is more. A 2- or 3-word subject line stands out in a crowded inbox of long sentences.
Formulas to Try:
“Quick idea”
“Worth a chat?”
“This week?”
Why It Works: Short subject lines cut through the noise visually. They’re easy to skim, and the simplicity can feel human rather than automated.
6. The Question Format
Questions create engagement because they invite a mental answer. If the question is relevant, the click feels like the natural next step.
Formulas to Try:
“Are you struggling with [pain point]?”
“What’s your plan for [upcoming trend]?”
“Is [specific solution] on your radar?”
Why It Works: It primes the reader for conversation. Cold outreach is often about opening dialogue, and this makes it feel two-sided from the subject line itself.
Putting It Together: The Testing Playbook
Here’s the reality: there’s no single “magic subject line.” What works for SaaS founders won’t necessarily work for HR leaders. But you can borrow these formulas and test systematically:
Start with 2–3 formulas — Run A/B tests with small batches (50–100 prospects per variation).
Track open rates + replies — A good subject line gets opens, but the real test is whether it flows into meaningful replies.
Rotate themes — Curiosity hooks might burn out faster, while value-driven lines have longer shelf life.
Layer personalization — Combine a formula with a custom detail (e.g., “Quick idea for (company name)”).
Final Thought
Think of subject lines as the “first five seconds” of your cold email. You don’t have to be the funniest, smartest, or most clever. You just need to be clear, relevant, and respectful of attention.
In practice, the winning subject lines aren’t the ones that win awards — they’re the ones that get opened, read, and replied to.
So test them. Keep a swipe file of what works in your niche. And remember: the subject line isn’t the end goal, it’s the key to unlocking the conversation that comes next.
Until next send,
The GTM Guild Team