The Art of Ethical Competitive Borrowing

In partnership with

Great outbound teams all do one thing exceptionally well: they study the market. Not only the prospects or the ICP, but also the other players trying to reach the same inboxes. Your competitors’ cold emails are a treasure trove of intelligence—but not because you should copy them. Copying is obvious, amateurish, and counterproductive. Instead, if you know how to examine competitors’ systems with a strategist’s mindset, you gain insight into what’s resonating, what’s failing, and what gaps you can exploit.

This edition of GTM Guild breaks down how to reverse-engineer competitor strategies, what signals to watch for, and how to translate those observations into stronger, differentiated messaging without mirroring or plagiarizing anyone’s playbook.

Why Competitor Analysis Matters in Outbound

Most cold outreach lives in a predictable pattern: similar offers, similar CTAs, similar tone. When everyone sounds the same, prospects tune out. Understanding what your competitors are sending tells you two things:

1. What prospects are already used to seeing
   This helps you avoid blending into the noise.

2. Where differentiation opportunities exist
   Even subtle shifts—tone, structure, insight density—can drastically increase reply rates.

Competitor analysis is not about imitation. It is about pattern recognition and positioning.

How to Ethically “Steal” Strategy Without Copying Execution

1. Study the Structure, Not the Sentences

Great outbound teams borrow patterns—not paragraphs.

Instead of asking, “What did they write?” ask, “How did they structure their message?”
Look for elements such as:

• Are they leading with a problem or with a claim?

• How long is the email?

• Is there a hook or a story?

• Do they use social proof early or later?

• What is the CTA style—soft, direct, or assumptive?

You’re analyzing architecture, not content.

Then apply the insights to your own context. If you notice others using overly generic openers, you can differentiate with specificity. If they rely on long paragraphs, you might win with brevity.

2. Observe the Emotional Strategy

Cold emails work when they trigger something—curiosity, fear of missing out, ambition, relief, efficiency, or status.

Study competitors to understand their emotional angle:

• Are they selling speed?

• Promising revenue?

• Emphasizing risk reduction?

• Appealing to innovation?

• Offering insider information?

Your goal is not to match their emotional angle but to spot overused ones. If everyone is selling speed, maybe you win on cost predictability. If everyone is pushing ROI, maybe you stand out by promising operational clarity.

Differentiation lives in emotional whitespace.

3. Map Out Their Sequencing Strategy

Cold email success is often more about sequencing than a single message. Look for:

• How many follow-ups they send

• The themes of each follow-up

• Whether follow-ups are value-driven or purely reminder-based

• The pacing (daily, every 3 days, weekly)

• Whether they close their sequences gracefully or aggressively

Studying sequences helps you learn what your ICP is being exposed to repeatedly.

If competitors send 7 reminders that say the same thing, you can win by making each follow-up a fresh insight. If they push for meetings in every email, you can test a softer CTA earlier in your sequence.

4. Identify Their Claims—Then Validate or Counterposition

Pay attention to the core messages competitors push:

• Do they emphasize one feature repeatedly?

• Do they anchor pricing or time savings?

• Do they rely on integrations, automation, or case studies?

These signals tell you:

• What they believe their strengths are

• How they want to shape the narrative

• What your prospects are being conditioned to expect

Use this intel to counterposition.
If they emphasize “automation,” maybe you highlight “control.”
If they lead with “ease of use,” maybe you emphasize “power and flexibility.”
If their proof points are shallow, you can win with depth.

Counterpositioning is not imitation; it is strategic contrast.

5. Track the Gaps They Don’t Address

Often, what competitors don’t mention is more revealing than what they do.

Look for:

• Problems they ignore

• Use cases they avoid

• Customer segments they neglect

• Risk areas they stay away from

• Claims they cannot confidently make

These become your opportunity zones.

Prospects instantly notice when your emails address gaps that others gloss over. It signals deeper expertise and increases trust.

6. Analyze Their Personalization Strategy

Are competitors:

• Using generic personalization?

• Hyperpersonalizing based on triggers?

• Referencing funding rounds?

• Using account-level insights?

• Automating with placeholders that feel robotic?

You don’t copy their personalization. You identify what level the market has normalized—then go one level deeper.

If everyone personalizes the same way, personalization stops feeling personal.

The advantage goes to the sender whose insight looks hand-crafted, even if it scales.

Turning Competitor Intelligence Into GTM Advantage

The goal is not to replicate what others are doing.
The goal is to understand the landscape so you can rise above it.

Ethical strategy borrowing means:

• Learn the structure

• Reject the sameness

• Build something stronger

• Lead with insight

• Zig when others zag

The best outbound doesn’t come from copying competitors—it comes from understanding them well enough to confidently diverge.

End Remarks

In a market where prospects receive near-identical cold emails every day, the teams that win aren’t the ones who copy competitors—they’re the ones who study the landscape, understand the patterns, and then deliberately choose to stand apart.

Ethical competitive borrowing is ultimately about sharpening your own strategic clarity. When you analyze others to elevate your originality, you build messaging that feels fresher, more relevant, and unmistakably yours. Outbound becomes less about following trends and more about setting them.

Until next time,

— Team GTM Guild