In partnership with

For over two decades, marketers have treated open rates as one of the most important indicators of email campaign performance. That tiny invisible tracking pixel embedded in emails told us whether recipients opened the message, giving teams a sense of engagement, subject line effectiveness, and list health.

But here’s the hard truth: your open rates are lying to you.

With Apple’s Mail Privacy Protection (MPP), Gmail’s evolving security practices, and growing user privacy expectations, pixel-based tracking has become unreliable. In this newsletter, we’ll unpack why open rates are falling apart, what that means for go-to-market strategies, and how smart teams are adapting.

The Problem with Pixel-Based Tracking

Pixel-based tracking works by embedding a 1x1 image in an email. When the recipient opens the message, their client fetches the image, signaling an “open.”

Sounds simple enough—until privacy features began breaking the model.

• Apple Mail Privacy Protection (2021): Apple started pre-loading tracking pixels for all users, making every email appear as “opened,” regardless of recipient behavior. For some senders, this inflated open rates by 30–50%.

• Gmail and others: Gmail caches images, which can prevent unique open tracking and delay signals.

• Ad blockers and security tools: Many now block tracking pixels altogether.

The result? A data set that’s noisy, inflated, and increasingly meaningless.

Why This Matters for GTM Leaders

For years, GTM teams used open rates to:

• A/B test subject lines.

• Identify engaged vs. inactive users.

• Trigger nurture campaigns or sales follow-ups.

• Clean mailing lists.

But if open data is unreliable, these strategies start breaking down. You might think your email strategy is working when, in reality, you’re chasing false signals. Worse, you might cut leads that look “unengaged” when in fact, they’re reading and clicking—just not triggering the pixel.

In short: open rates are no longer a dependable KPI.

The Shift Toward Meaningful Metrics

So, what should GTM teams do instead? The answer is to focus on metrics that truly reflect engagement and revenue impact.

• Click-through rates (CTR): Still trackable and a direct measure of engagement with your message.

• Conversion rates: Whether it’s booking a demo, signing up, or making a purchase, this is the gold standard.

• Reply rates: For sales outreach, a reply is infinitely more valuable than an “open.”

• List health (deliverability + engagement): Look at bounce rates, spam complaints, and unsubscribes as indicators of overall audience quality.

• Time-to-value: Instead of vanity metrics, measure how fast emails are helping leads move down the funnel.

By shifting focus from “did they open it?” to “did it matter to them?”, teams align email with broader GTM goals.

How Smart Teams Are Adapting

Forward-thinking companies aren’t mourning the loss of open rates—they’re retooling. Here’s how:

1. Experiment with send time differently: Instead of relying on open tracking, test click engagement over time slots.

2. Personalize beyond the subject line: Crafting content that resonates increases the likelihood of real actions (clicks, replies).

3. Double down on segmentation: Smaller, well-targeted lists outperform spray-and-pray tactics, regardless of open metrics.

4. Invest in first-party data: Use owned signals—like web analytics, product usage, or CRM engagement—to trigger follow-ups instead of pixel-based opens.

5. Redefine success internally: Educate teams and leadership that “open rates” are outdated, shifting conversations toward ROI-driven KPIs.

A Case in Point

Consider a SaaS startup that built their nurturing flow around “non-openers.” After Apple MPP, their open rates shot up by 40%. The problem? Their “non-opener re-engagement” campaign dwindled to a tiny pool. Yet, conversions didn’t rise—they stayed flat.

Once the team restructured around click and conversion data instead of opens, they discovered that many “ghost openers” weren’t actually engaging. By pivoting, they improved CTR by 25% and demo bookings by 18% in just two months.

The lesson: chasing opens wastes time; chasing outcomes drives growth.

The Future of Email Measurement

The fall of pixel-based tracking is part of a larger shift toward privacy-first marketing. Just like third-party cookies, tracking pixels are slowly becoming relics of the past. Tomorrow’s GTM leaders will thrive by embracing transparency, relevance, and user trust as the foundations of engagement.

Instead of lamenting the loss of a shaky metric, think of this as an opportunity. Without the distraction of inflated open rates, your team can focus on what truly matters: building relationships, delivering value, and driving measurable business results.

Final Word

The next time your dashboard shows a spike in open rates, remember: it may be nothing more than a phantom signal. True GTM advantage lies not in chasing artificial metrics, but in tracking actions that align with outcomes.

So, retire your obsession with opens. The fall of pixel-based tracking isn’t the end of email marketing—it’s the beginning of a smarter, outcome-driven era.

Until next drop,

— GTM Guild Team